This story is a part of your SHN+ subscription.
Many senior dwelling operators had hoped {that a} new Congress and president in 2025 would imply a extra favorable enterprise and regulatory surroundings. However the headlines this week inform a really completely different story.
World markets plunged on the information of the Trump Administration’s tariff coverage; the S&P 500 skilled its greatest single-day loss since 2020.
Enterprise leaders throughout all industries are affected by the tariffs and ensuing market turmoil and uncertainty, and senior dwelling is actually not immune. However the sector additionally was hit with a way more direct growth, which reveals that even with a brand new administration within the White Home, Democratic lawmakers are nonetheless pushing ahead with scrutiny that started below President Biden. Particularly, a letter from three senators is asking for a governmental evaluation of assisted dwelling.
The letter, from Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) and Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), asks the Authorities Accountability Workplace (GAO) to evaluation and replace its 2018 report on state and federal oversight of assisted dwelling services that take part in Medicaid. The letter particularly duties the company with reviewing how nicely CMS and state Medicaid applications look after and “defend the a whole bunch of hundreds of seniors and people with disabilities who reside in these services.”
A request of this nature might take months or years to finish. And senior dwelling trade trade associations consider it’s not going the present administration would improve federal oversight of assisted dwelling communities that take Medicaid {dollars}.
Regardless of these caveats, this letter reveals the highlight remains to be very a lot on senior dwelling operators in 2025. And whereas I agree the present administration and Congress in all probability received’t do a lot with present requires extra federal oversight, I believe it’s solely a matter of time earlier than that adjustments, given the trade’s curiosity in such companies to serve a wider group of older adults.
The trade is dealing with an “intensive training battle” in 2025 amid continued scrutiny from lawmakers, to not point out most people, Argentum Senior Vice President of Public Coverage Maggie Elehwany lately informed SHN. As I’ve mentioned earlier than, I believe that’s each a danger and a chance. And I believe that the senior dwelling trade’s battle for higher PR is barely getting began.
On this week’s members-only SHN+ Replace, I analyze the current name for extra oversight on Medicaid assisted dwelling and provide the next takeaways:
- Inside current oversight traits in assisted dwelling
- Why lawmakers have renewed requires federal oversight of assisted dwelling in 2025
- The chance and alternative of senior dwelling’s ongoing “training battle”
AL oversight traits and what might come subsequent
Though assisted dwelling communities are topic to federal rules regarding employment and discrimination, they lack the extra in depth rules governing expert nursing operators. As a substitute, assisted dwelling is basically regulated on the state stage.
Medicaid doesn’t cowl room and board prices, however sure states enable eligible residents to make use of Medicaid waivers to cowl private care companies. Nearly 18% of assisted dwelling residents at the moment depend on Medicaid to cowl each day care, in keeping with AHCA/NCAL.
Greater than 1 / 4 of states (29%) made regulatory or legislative adjustments that impacted assisted dwelling residents, employees, and facility operations between July 2023, and July 2024, in keeping with AHCA/NCAL stats. A complete of 45 states and Washington, D.C., have an infection management necessities for assisted dwelling, whereas 25 have high quality measurement, knowledge assortment, or high quality administration necessities for such operators.
This patchwork of rules is partly why some lawmakers are so centered on enhancing federal oversight. In line with the letter from Warren, Wyden and Gillibrand, that “lack of federal necessities and variation in state necessities might impede efforts to determine patterns of incidents in assisted dwelling services that have an effect on resident well being and welfare, equivalent to abuse and neglect, or different issues affecting residents, equivalent to evictions.”
The senators cited the 2023 reporting from the Washington Submit displaying hundreds of instances the place senior dwelling residents wandered away from their communities – reporting that ultimately helped immediate a 2024 Senate evaluation that included testimony from Gardant Co-President Julie Simpkins.
A 2018 GAO report discovered that almost all of state Medicaid businesses didn’t observe “crucial incidents” affecting Medicaid beneficiaries dwelling in assisted dwelling communities. The current letter from the trio of lawmakers is supposed to alter that, and they’re searching for extra data on how states oversee residents’ well being and wellness, how they observe deficiencies and different incidents, how CMS is implementing necessities for state Medicaid applications and whether or not there’s a want for extra federal oversight of assisted dwelling.
These sorts of requires oversight aren’t notably new, and Warren and others have urged the federal authorities to contemplate extra oversight of assisted dwelling prior to now. However I believe they’ll solely proceed and develop as extra child boomers transfer into senior housing – or don’t, as a result of affordability points.
For now, there has not been a lot political will to enact assisted dwelling oversight on the federal stage. However as extra boomers transfer into senior dwelling communities, they’ll little question anticipate legislators to handle their wants.
I additionally take into consideration the variety of senior dwelling operators rising with the middle-market in thoughts. As Simpkins famous through the Senate listening to final yr, applications like Medicaid waivers might assist operators decrease their charges and widen the quantity of people that can afford their companies.
“With a quickly rising aged inhabitants, we’d like a private and non-private partnership to incentivize extra suppliers to develop these fashions,” she mentioned.
I agree – however I believe the tradeoff to those sorts of preparations is permitting extra oversight in assisted dwelling.
The catch right here may very well be that Medicaid could be very a lot within the crosshairs of drastic federal funds cuts which are being pursued. So, assisted dwelling suppliers concerned within the Medicaid market are in a nasty place, dealing with the prospect of potential reductions in Medicaid income or adjustments to waiver applications because of the GOP-led funds cuts, in addition to Democratic requires tighter oversight and regulation. The actual losers right here may very well be older adults, if these actions from either side of the aisle stifle Medicaid-related middle-market improvements whereas squeezing current suppliers within the Medicaid market a lot that they pause progress, shrink their footprints, exit of enterprise, or pivot to completely different fashions, additional limiting entry to AL at a cheaper price level.
Senior dwelling’s training struggle simply getting began
To me, the present highlight on senior dwelling is unwelcome however may very well be turned to suppliers’ benefit.
On the one hand, senior dwelling operators discover themselves grappling with a skeptical public in regards to the high quality and price of their companies. That isn’t a straightforward dialog to have, particularly as operators justify why senior dwelling is value its comparatively excessive value.
Polling from Gallup in 2023 confirmed that greater than 40% of People give nursing properties a D or F score. To be clear, this was a ballot about nursing properties, not assisted dwelling. Though I believe their notion of senior dwelling is barely higher given the extra lifestyle-oriented nature of private-pay communities, I additionally assume current tales from the Submit and elsewhere have led to a lower than stellar status within the public’s eyes–and as Expert Nursing Information lately reported, customers nonetheless largely conflate nursing properties with different forms of senior dwelling and care, as mirrored of their web search habits.
Then again, that highlight on the trade means operators have an opportunity to showcase what they do finest. If senior dwelling corporations actually can reveal that their care is comparatively inexpensive and high-quality for the companies they provide, I believe they’ve an actual alternative to show across the dialog.
To that finish, some senior dwelling operators, together with Sonida Senior Residing (NYSE: SNDA) and Brookdale Senior Residing (NYSE: BKD) already are attempting to attraction on to customers by rising in-house advertising and marketing and relying much less on nationwide third-party referral sources.
As I famous, I believe the trade’s public notion battle is barely getting began, and can intensify within the coming years as extra older adults study senior dwelling companies firsthand. The problem for operators will probably be to not disguise from the highlight, however to thrive in it and present the general public they’re well-equipped to look after a brand new technology of residents.
