This story is a part of your SHN+ subscription
Welltower held its fourth-quarter earnings name earlier this week, and a remark from CEO Shankh Mitra caught my ear.
Through the name, he acknowledged that “a number of well being care REITs and personal funds” aside from Welltower are assembling senior housing working portfolios (SHOP), and warned that such offers are usually not all the time a simple win. Mitra was referring to the latest wave of different senior housing REITs creating SHOP segments in an effort to hunt larger alignment with working companions.
Whereas he acknowledged that “these are succesful organizations,” his private opinion can be that a minimum of a few of them will come to “respect that writing credit score checks could be very completely different from proudly owning fairness in a fancy and operationally intensive enterprise that can’t be addressed just by hiring just a few asset managers to handle the managers.”
In a nutshell, Mitra believes that senior residing operators should have the infrastructure to help rising working platforms. It’s a lesson he’s discovered from expertise, having helped lead the corporate to pivot from a majority triple-net portfolio to 1 weighed closely towards SHOP since its “re-founding” a decade in the past.
“These are full-cycle classes and shall be discovered as such,” Mitra mentioned. “Publicity alone doesn’t outline success on this difficult terrain.”
As Mitra famous, a number of REITs and different corporations are in 2026 leaping into the SHOP pool. It’s no secret beginning a SHOP section isn’t as simple as simply shopping for properties and pairing them with operators, and corporations that don’t heed these classes might discover themselves overexposed if issues don’t go as deliberate.
On this members-only SHN+ Replace, I analyze Mitra’s latest phrases of warning and previous few years of RIDEA development amongst REITs to supply the next takeaways:
- The teachings Welltower discovered about SHOP within the final 10 years
- Why RIDEA hinges on infrastructure and help
- The place I believe different corporations may misstep of their SHOP methods
Mitra’s warning knowledgeable by decade of RIDEA development
Behind Mitra’s phrases of warning is a historical past of hammering out new and higher RIDEA agreements with working companions.
A couple of decade in the past, the REIT rebranded from Well being Care REIT to Welltower. Whereas the corporate had already in 2010 inked its first first RIDEA contract with Merrill Gardens as working companion, the corporate’s actual evolution didn’t start till the years between 2016 and 2020.
Greater than a decade in the past, “misaligned incentives as a result of revenue-based administration contracts” gave property house owners “restricted flexibility and optionality, given extremely restrictive termination rights,” Welltower administration wrote in a 2025 enterprise replace. Between 2015 and 2020, Welltower hammered out a number of RIDEA iterations to extend alignment with its working companions. Now, the corporate is on its 6.0 RIDEA iteration.
All through the years, Welltower has tweaked its RIDEA construction to extend alignment with its working companions. Right now, the corporate blends actual property – what administration calls its “{hardware} – with operational and technological capabilities, which administration calls its “software program.”
Underpinning Welltower’s RIDEA construction is a slate of help for working companions that features information insights and makes use of machine studying to assist make higher capital allocation and working platform selections. The REIT additionally has sought to extend alignment between itself and operators by means of applications like the Welltower Fellowship Grant it launched late final yr, which awards frontline staff on the firm’s top-performing communities with shares from a pool value tens of millions of {dollars}.
Mitra has mentioned earlier than the REIT is like Dwelling Depot, Amazon and Costco in that it could actually use information and scale to enhance efficiency on the bottom and develop its “community impact,” that means the phenomenon the place a services or products’s potential buyer base will increase as extra folks purchase or use it.
“This vertically built-in software program plus {hardware} mannequin goals to scale back latency throughout the stack of determination making and put the community impact into operational execution,” Mitra mentioned throughout the firm’s earnings name this week. “This immediately feeds into our capital allocation flywheel, driving execution into excessive gear in 2025, which we’re more likely to observe once more in 2026.”
Zooming the lens again in, that is all context to contemplate in mild of Mitra’s phrases of warning earlier this week. He has had a front-row seat to the final decade-plus of discovering alignment between senior residing operators and house owners. He has repeatedly burdened that senior residing isn’t a enterprise the place one can merely “write a examine” and watch cash roll in. It’s an operationally intensive enterprise, and with out a layer of help, even well-planned SHOP efforts may collapse.
To carry again the SHOP “pool” analogy, Welltower has spent the final decade studying what it takes to swim in uneven waters – these leaping into the pool at the moment haven’t. Except they’ll study what it takes to swim, they may sink to the underside.
Stated one other manner, I believe Mitra was saying along with his warning that it took Welltower a decade to get its RIDEA contracts to their present state. He has lengthy described what he sees as an absence of alignment between operators and house owners of communities. With out realizing what it takes to bridge that hole, corporations with burgeoning SHOP segments must study probably painful classes by themselves, simply as Welltower has performed.
SHOP success rides on help for operators
Mitra isn’t the one senior residing govt who feels that senior residing alignment rests on a REIT’s capability to supply help to its working companions. Final yr, I had the prospect to sit down down with Justin Hutchens, govt vice chairman of senior housing and chief funding officer at Ventas, who walked me by means of the firm’s playbook for working with its working companions.
Hutchens and Ventas CEO Debra Cafaro have lengthy touted the corporate’s “proper market, proper asset, proper operator” technique as a differentiator. Because the title implies, the REIT is looking for to pair high quality operators with communities and markets they’ll achieve. All of the whereas, the REIT is giving its working companions entry to market benchmarks, data on charges, competitors and different insights to assist enhance their efficiency.
“We’re going to level you on to the chance the place you may make the most important influence the quickest,” Hutchens instructed me. “The trouble could be very collaborative, and that’s essential, as a result of on the finish of day, the managers are working this enterprise.”
Whereas Mitra didn’t title any names when he spoke of “a number of well being care REITs and personal funds leaping into SHOP” and “hiring just a few asset managers to handle the managers,” I couldn’t assist however consider Janus Residing, the latest spinoff from senior housing REIT Healthpeak (NYSE: DOC) that’s launching with a 34-community, 10,422-unit senior housing portfolio in 10 states. Janus is about to personal all of its properties in a RIDEA operational construction and Healthpeak is performing as its exterior supervisor with a considerable possession stake within the spinoff.
That’s to not say Janus Residing isn’t pondering of supporting its working companions. Healthpeak is bringing in operators Pegasus Senior Residing and Ciel Senior Residing with contracts that embrace “sturdy alignment by means of efficiency incentives,” the corporate famous.
Once more, I wish to stress that I don’t have a lot perception into Janus Residing or Healthpeak’s plans with it. However I do consider that the technique of alignment will relaxation on how properly Healthpeak can help its working companions.
Most of the traders constructing out SHOP methods have deep expertise within the senior residing sector and significant relationships with sturdy operators. Janus isn’t any exception, given Healthpeak’s historical past going again to its days as HCP in senior residing. However to the purpose Mitra was making, this expertise within the area isn’t any assure of SHOP success, and the leaders of those newer SHOP gamers may stumble in the event that they put an excessive amount of inventory in what they already know and don’t function from a spot of humility about what they should study.
Ultimately it took Welltower 10 years to land on its present RIDEA construction, and with out heeding his recommendation, I believe it may take different corporations a equally very long time to take action. Whether or not they have the time to determine it out is one other query.
