This story is a part of your SHN+ subscription
As mid-size and bigger senior dwelling operators search development with institutional capital companions, smaller or single-site suppliers in secondary and tertiary markets danger falling right into a type of operational or monetary “purgatory.”
Given their fewer assets, smaller senior dwelling communities and suppliers are at an obstacle when competing with bigger corporations which have deeper pockets. On the similar time, smaller properties beneath 60 items are sometimes beneath the margins threshold wanted to make for a gorgeous acquisition from present patrons.
House owners and operators of those properties can get locked in a cycle whereby they tread water with little to no likelihood of a sale or recap, a phenomenon that Phoenix Senior Dwelling CEO Jesse Marinko dubbed a type of “purgatory.”
“There’ll at all times be a distinct segment for a mom-and-pop operator, however rising from one location to 2, I feel there’s such an invisible ceiling for these teams as a result of institutional capital companions require an enormous funding to fulfill their reporting wants,” Marinko advised me.
If the senior dwelling trade had been a forest, giant senior dwelling operators would represent the bushes and cover, whereas smaller operators can be the ferns on the forest flooring. Nature dictates that there’s room for each – however provided that the ferns can get the daylight and vitamins they should develop.
Zooming out the lens, I feel competitors from bigger suppliers will immediate smaller corporations to shift priorities additional towards needs-based and specialised providers, like assisted dwelling and reminiscence care, in an try to eke out their spot within the solar. I additionally suppose they should pair these efforts with knowledge assortment and staffing creativity with a view to survive and even thrive.
On this week’s unique, subscribers-only SHN+ Replace, I unpack the next dynamics of small and enormous operators and supply the next takeaways:
- How transaction exercise uncovers challenges small operators face
- Unpacking the present boundaries to entry in senior dwelling
‘Very difficult’ for smaller properties in 2025
The senior dwelling transaction setting is witnessing a “excellent storm” revolving round slowed growth begins, which has led to elevated transactions in 2025. However regardless of an uptick in M&A, the senior dwelling trade stays extremely fragmented.
Based on a 2021 report from Nationwide Council of Actual Property Funding Fiduciaries (NCREIF), greater than half of the senior dwelling market is managed by small proprietor operators with fewer than 10 communities.
In 2025, it’s nonetheless “very difficult” to promote smaller senior dwelling properties, significantly in secondary or tertiary markets, Senior Dwelling Funding Brokerage (SLIB) Govt Vice President Dave Balow advised me. That’s as a result of smaller properties underneath 60 beds are beneath the web working earnings threshold wanted with a view to make an asset a gorgeous acquisition to present patrons.
“We frequently see non-public house owners run at a lot decrease margins than teams who’ve extra scale,” Balow stated. “With inflation, much less buying energy, staffing pressures and company staffing use, and normal competitors for residents, it’s getting more durable and more durable to function as a non-public proprietor.”
Whereas Balow sees a future by which small senior dwelling operators can nonetheless compete towards bigger suppliers, the dynamics of smaller communities will stay dramatically totally different than bigger ones, with slimmer margins, lowered buying energy and no company help.That would push extra house owners towards the prospect of consolidation, affiliation or sale to exit the trade, if they’ll promote their communities for the proper worth, that’s.
As soon as bigger and newer properties have been acquired or all traded fingers, traders might flip their curiosity again to the sorts of communities they acquired within the 90s and early 2000s, Marinko advised me.
“For the following six to 10 years, I feel you’re going to see little or no institutional capital getting in secondary and tertiary markets,” Marinko advised me.
Teams with bigger scale are extra shortly capable of spend money on programs, expertise and neighborhood enhancements in comparison with smaller operators’ capacity to fulfill monetary reporting benchmarks and climate the numerous working challenges they face.
Smaller communities additionally face “increased variability” in occupancy and smaller suppliers should unfold fastened prices over a smaller unit base, Macquarie Capital Belongings Senior Healthcare Fairness Analysis Analyst Tao Qiu advised me. Discovering the correct mix of workers can be a problem for smaller operators, in comparison with bigger properties with devoted recruitment groups.
“Institutional capital brings to the desk assets to spend money on these improvements and evolutions, along with enhanced monetary self-discipline and operational sophistication,” Qiu advised me. “I feel right this moment’s traders perceive that roll-ups don’t essentially work effectively except you’ve got a neighborhood technique.”
Historical past has proven that regional and native senior dwelling fashions can compete towards nationwide platforms the place every little thing is centralized in a company workplace, as seen within the rebalancing of senior dwelling traders swapping out working companions following the Covid-19 pandemic and administration transitions executed during the last two years.
Given the dearth of latest growth, even small- footprint communities might replenish within the coming decade given surging demand, Qiu stated. However as SHN has famous earlier than, now just isn’t the time for senior dwelling operators to relaxation on their laurels. Whereas I do suppose smaller operators have an distinctive alternative to face out amongst opponents and reap demand, it is going to take providers that residents and their households need.
For instance, small-home senior dwelling operator Sage Oak is personalizing its reminiscence care providers for residents by a program it launched final yr known as Curated Care. This system provides the Dallas, Texas-based operator the flexibility to overview resident well being info and knowledge to position residents based mostly on their acuity stage, programming preferences, social tendencies and care necessities. Utilizing that strategy, Sage Oak has been capable of preserve an occupancy charge within the mid-90s all through the Covid-19 pandemic, CEO Loe Hornbuckle has advised us in recent times.
Smaller operators can leverage their local-market information and connections to construct stronger relationships with households and achieve their belief over bigger, extra impersonal corporations. .
“The actually good operators can straddle the 2 methods of being a neighborhood useful resource households are accustomed to,” Marinko stated. However he added that he additionally believes bigger corporations can succeed with “help and assets ahead which might be solely out there to operators with scale and help groups.”
Avoiding ‘purgatory territory’ in senior dwelling administration
Senior dwelling operators have grown shortly in recent times in an effort to rebound from the early days of the Covid-19 pandemic.
In right this moment’s working setting, margin compression stays the most important problem suppliers face, Marinko stated., He famous that it’s powerful for administration corporations to show a revenue with out the assets afforded by a big, institutional capital accomplice.
There’s a “purgatory territory” that some senior dwelling operators can fall into that features between 5 and 30 properties the place “you simply don’t make cash” in operations because of the assets wanted to fill communities with workers throughout varied departments, Marinko added.
“I feel being a senior housing operator is much less enticing within the house proper now as a result of it’s in regards to the barrier to entry, value of doing enterprise and it’s a income construction that hasn’t modified in a long time,” Marinko advised me.
In an effort to keep away from “purgatory” in scale and income, right this moment’s senior dwelling operators should get artistic in constructing new capital relationships, from administration contracts evolving to the revenue acquired by the operator rising.
I’m assured that smaller senior dwelling corporations can compete towards bigger suppliers resulting from their capacity to harness grassroots advertising and marketing and a deep base of native information to personalize providers and stand out. However what number of really will is one other query.
As possession companions require extra monetary reporting from their operators, small and enormous suppliers have their work lower out for them and the trade should adapt to fulfill the rising variety of older adults in want of senior dwelling.
