This text is a part of your SHN+ subscription
For years, senior dwelling operators have tried in useless to extend common penetration charges. In 2024, it’s the trade’s “holy grail.”
In case you’ve learn Senior Housing Information at any level within the final decade, then you might be most likely conscious that penetration charges have been caught, with current NIC information pegging such charges at between 10% and 12% nationally.
Given the demand for senior dwelling forward, it could be logical to assume penetration charges will rise on their very own within the years to return. However I recall the phrases of trade visionary and Nexus Insights Founder Bob Kramer, who advised Senior Housing Information earlier this yr that it isn’t a foregone conclusion if operators don’t additionally innovate.
“If we expect we’re going to check out the identical product the identical means – and have even the identical penetration charge, not to mention the next penetration charge – I believe we’re naive,” he mentioned.
I additionally imagine senior dwelling operators should go additional than what they provide right this moment to develop penetration charges. However the precise nature of why the trade’s total penetration charge stays muted continues to be considerably of a thriller, NIC Head of Analysis and Analytics Lisa McCracken advised me.
“Determining the ‘why’ behind the [penetration rate] of senior dwelling is the holy grail to maneuver the needle, and we’re not there but—it’s difficult,” she mentioned.
Thriller or not, I believe it’s clear that operators should change gross sales and advertising and marketing practices to succeed in new customers and higher current the worth of their companies to potential residents.
On this week’s members-only, unique SHN+ Replace, I analyze the present state of senior dwelling demand and penetration charges, together with:
– Fixing the puzzle of comparatively caught penetration charges
– Why impartial dwelling penetration charges are stagnant
– The way it all comes all the way down to exhibiting prospects worth
Senior dwelling penetration charges a ‘difficult puzzle to resolve’
On paper, the trade’s demand outlook is stellar.
The U.S. Census Bureau tasks that by 2030, 73 million child boomers will probably be 65 years previous, and 34 million older adults will probably be 70 years previous in that very same interval. Based on the Nationwide Institutes of Well being, these 85 and older are the fastest-growing cohort of the U.S. inhabitants.
However occupied penetration charges inform a barely totally different story.
Senior dwelling occupied penetration charges for assisted dwelling and reminiscence care items elevated 3.9% and 1.4%, respectively, within the 31 main markets NIC tracks between 2017 and 2023. Impartial dwelling’s occupied penetration charge, in the meantime, is now 4%, which is three proportion factors beneath the place these charges had been in 2017.
In 2023, U.S. markets with the very best total occupied penetration charges included Minneapolis (21.6%), Portland (19.2%), Seattle (14.6%), Kansas Metropolis (14.4%), Denver (13.5%), and Dallas (13.3%). New York and Las Vegas got here in on the backside of the pile with penetration charges of 4.3% and 4.2%, respectively.
Coastal and metropolitan markets are additionally recovering extra shortly and reporting increased penetration charges since 2017, in accordance with NIC information. This uneven nature of restoration and margin enlargement may very well be a chance for operators to try to higher join with these in rural markets, as 17% of these 65 and older dwell in non-metro markets, in accordance with federal census information.
The uneven occupied penetration charges throughout the trade are doubtless as a consequence of modifications in demand dynamics and migration patterns, in accordance with the abstract by NIC Principal Omar Zahraoui. We’ve persistently heard from operators lately because the needs-based senior dwelling continues to drive demand.
However even with that information, Zahraoui mentioned the senior dwelling trade’s total penetration charge on the nationwide degree “stays a difficult puzzle to resolve.”
At the same time as occupancy continues to enhance nationwide for operators, the lower in occupied penetration charges noticed by NIC Analytics inside impartial dwelling – coupled with the truth that penetration charges are nonetheless comparatively caught elsewhere – must be a warning for all senior dwelling operators.
On the impartial dwelling aspect, operators are being squeezed by energetic grownup, a product kind that may feel and appear like impartial dwelling to most of the people regardless of its apparent variations. Impartial dwelling communities are additionally typically dearer than energetic grownup properties.
The incoming era of older adults want affordability and socialization of their housing choices, bins that energetic grownup communities can test. If impartial dwelling operators don’t differentiate their companies or present the worth of what they supply, I imagine they are going to be at a drawback.
“If you want to say these are your promoting factors, you’ve probably acquired somewhat extra work to do, and it’s much more of a gross sales job by an operator to say, ‘Are you able to be a greater model of your self in a group than what you may be in your personal house,’” McCracken advised me.
With demand for assisted dwelling and reminiscence care sturdy as a consequence of underlying needs-driven dynamics of every sector, the high-acuity development witnessed by operators lately is “nonetheless the story right here,” Zahraoui advised me.
Within the final 4 years, the build-back and restoration of assisted dwelling and reminiscence care have been faster than impartial dwelling, Zahraoui mentioned. That’s due partly to residents as soon as in impartial dwelling in 2020 having progressed to assisted dwelling or reminiscence care.
“That’s truly influencing the demand for assisted dwelling and reminiscence care,” he added.
Some operators, together with Tutera Senior Dwelling, Atlas Senior Dwelling and Anthem Reminiscence Care have embraced development methods with high-acuity senior dwelling in thoughts. For instance, Tutera President and COO Randy Bloom lately advised my colleague Andrew Christman in regards to the firm’s give attention to “specialised coaching and new staffing fashions” to arrange for a extra acute senior dwelling atmosphere.
However regardless of the inherent demand of needs-based care, assisted dwelling and reminiscence care are additionally prohibitively costly for a large swath of child boomers, totaling greater than half of the cohort by 2030. Even when older adults want these companies, prices are a rising and infrequently insurmountable barrier to purchasing them.
So, discovering a scalable middle-market senior dwelling mannequin would symbolize enormous step ahead within the quest for increased penetration charges. Nevertheless, I additionally assume that suppliers can and should do a greater job of exhibiting how present market charges are an affordable and even good worth, given all that senior dwelling can ship to residents. There are various methods to try this, together with exhibiting the profit of senior dwelling resident well being outcomes and prioritizing value-based companies that embrace wellness and different common service choices.
On the finish of the day, I imagine that creating fashions of senior dwelling that attraction to the following era of customers and successfully advertising and marketing the worth of senior dwelling are essential steps in driving penetration charges, however they’re additionally big-picture challenges with no simple or fast answer.
‘Laid-back’ gross sales method an issue
I believe it’s potential that the sector might see a extra fast jolt to penetration charges by tightening up a chronically troubled gross sales course of. For one, senior dwelling suppliers nonetheless aren’t at all times speaking to their prospects in a well timed vogue, in accordance with current information from advertising and marketing consultancy Bild & Co.
Bild & Co. information of over 220 communities in 11 states present that over half (51%) of thriller outlets that submitted an internet kind contact request for extra data didn’t obtain a personalised response inside two hours and 12% of these inquiries didn’t obtain a return name after 24 hours.
“We’re nonetheless seeing this laid-back method, however velocity is king,” Bild & Co. CEO Jennifer Saxman advised me. “Velocity to guide is what you’ve acquired to be targeted on greater than anything.”
The disconnect between the advertising and marketing workforce’s messaging and the gross sales workforce’s execution highlights the necessity for important enhancements in senior dwelling gross sales practices to align with present demand.
Whereas some operators have equated inquiries for data concerning a group as very important as a senior dwelling “911 name,” it’s clear that there’s nonetheless a lot work to be finished in shifting the practices of senior dwelling gross sales groups.
“In case you don’t carry a lead by way of all the gross sales cycle, you’re going to proceed to wrestle,” Saxman mentioned. “I don’t assume we do a terrific job of participating our purchaser proper now.”
This comes because the trade has turn into in some methods “very dependent” on paid referrals, Saxman mentioned, whilst American Seniors Housing Affiliation (ASHA) President Dave Schless advised me lately that there was “misalignment” between operators and paid referral sources.
To interrupt by way of that misalignment, ASHA is within the midst of a relaunch for The place You Stay Issues, its senior dwelling referral web site that’s aiming to turn into an impartial referral service to attach customers on to operators.
Robert Grammatica, who supplied technical help within the buildout of ASHA’s The place You Stay Issues 2.0, advised me that the trade is “not telling the proper story” in attracting potential residents to communities. I agree.
I’ve written advert nauseam on the significance of integrating know-how into senior dwelling operations since I began writing on the sector in 2022, but when operators are gradual to showcase these efforts, their advertising and marketing potential will probably be for naught.
Bettering the senior dwelling gross sales cycle to be extra dynamic and responsive will probably be key for operators to develop market penetration and totally seize the rising tide of demand that’s starting to swell on the trade’s shores.
