This story is a part of your SHN+ subscription
This week, Dept. of Well being and Human Providers (HHS) Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. demanded the firing or resignation of CDC director Susan Monarez in a transfer that alarmed public well being specialists.
Additionally earlier this week, rumors swirled over whether or not the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention (CDC) may pull the Covid-19 vaccine off the market altogether inside months. One other U.S. company, the Meals and Drug Administration (FDA), additionally this week narrowed its tips for who ought to get the Covid-19 vaccine to adults aged 65 and older and folks with danger components like weight problems or a historical past of smoking.
The latest tried firing, walk-outs and exodus of high CDC employees and potential forthcoming adjustments in vaccine authorization paint a troubled image on the public well being company. Kennedy himself mentioned as a lot when he advised Fox Information Thursday that he’s “fixing” the CDC, “and it might be that some individuals shouldn’t be working there anymore.”
Expert nursing operators whose cost is tied to federal reimbursements from HHS know properly the affect of presidency company dysfunction. Conventional senior dwelling operators cost residents principally private-pay charges, and thus are extra remoted from such authorities turmoil.
However the CDC performed an essential function within the senior dwelling trade’s preliminary pivot from stay-in-place restrictions to reopening to the world. State governments, supported by steerage from the CDC, helped operators decide what to do and to not do to maintain residents properly whereas data was sparse. Considering again to 2021, I keep in mind the optimism and hope that senior dwelling leaders felt as they rolled up their sleeves and joined residents and employees in getting their first vaccine doses. In 2025, I fear that second could now be eclipsed by rash choices pushed by new and unfounded vaccine skepticism from public well being leaders, and that it’ll go away senior dwelling operators — to not point out the broader nation — extra prone to illness ultimately.
In the previous couple of years, I’ve talked with many senior dwelling leaders who’ve pivoted from the “Covid days” to extra hopeful progress and evolution efforts. And it’s not unusual to listen to individuals at senior dwelling conferences bemoaning point out of “the C-word,” not less than in my expertise.
However new Covid-19 circumstances are nonetheless cropping up day-after-day throughout the U.S. As I write this Replace, a Covid variant known as “Stratus” is resulting in a new increase of infections in lots of states. Whereas deaths from Covid are far decrease than they have been 5 years in the past, individuals coming down with the illness nonetheless generally grapple with signs for months or years. And even when communities aren’t shutting down for weeks on finish like within the darkest days of 2020, Covid can nonetheless trigger disruptions in different, smaller methods, such employees calling in sick or residents staying house for longer.
Whether or not operators prefer it or not, Covid continues to be a drive to be reckoned with of their communities. Provided that the CDC as soon as helped senior dwelling operators by way of a tricky interval, I feel the trade needs to be not less than considerably involved concerning the turmoil on the high of the company, if it’s not already. Though there are extra authorized hurdles the Trump administration must comply with to additional limit the Covid-19 vaccine or take it off the market, even the mere dialogue of proscribing a life-saving vaccine is alarming to me personally. I additionally fear the issue might lengthen past Covid and into doubtlessly different essential vaccines that senior dwelling operators use to maintain residents protected.
On this members-only SHN+ Replace, I analyze the CDC’s latest issues together with historical past and provide the next takeaways:
- A glance again to how the Covid-19 vaccine began the senior dwelling trade’s newest restoration
- Why accessing the Covid-19 vaccine and different vaccines is essential for the senior dwelling trade’s future
- How CDC turmoil imperils the trade’s skill to reply to different endemic illnesses or outbreaks
Covid-19 vaccine performed important function in trade’s restoration
Days earlier than Christmas in 2020, I used to be speaking on the telephone with then-Atria CEO John Moore. Atria was among the many very first senior dwelling operators within the U.S. to start doling out Covid photographs to residents in its communities, and I nonetheless keep in mind the joy and hope in his voice as he described the corporate’s ongoing rollout. Within the months and years following that second, numerous senior dwelling operators organized vaccine clinics for residents on bold timelines.
Photograph courtesy Vacation RetirementAt present, the information exhibits that they have been proper in doing so. A 2023 research from NIC and NORC on the College of Chicago discovered that, after the primary Covid vaccines have been obtainable, older adults dwelling in congregate senior dwelling communities didn’t have the next danger of dying from the illness in comparison with older adults dwelling in non-congregate settings, akin to at house.
Whereas that may not appear so spectacular on its face, understand that senior dwelling communities have been like tinder for the fast-spreading pandemic given the nearer proximity of residents to one another and employees, and that individuals 65 and older are at larger danger of extreme illness.
The NIC/NORC research confirmed that senior dwelling communities might really maintain older adults about as protected from the illness as in the event that they have been dwelling alone, even whereas these residents lived nearer to at least one one other. CCRCs particularly had even decrease ranges of loss of life than that, based on the researchers.
Covid-19 initially amounted to an enormous PR hit for senior dwelling operators and expert nursing suppliers as many residents delayed their transfer for longer. Quick-forward to 2025 and plenty of operators have been capable of win again the belief of skeptical residents, mirrored in larger occupancy of their communities. Higher resident well being care and an infection management have been essential operational instruments used to win again that belief.
At present, older adults are transferring into senior dwelling communities at document charges partially resulting from a traditionally low charge of latest development, and I assume not less than a few of the older adults who delayed transferring in in the course of the Covid-19 pandemic at the moment are dwelling in a senior dwelling neighborhood.
However I additionally consider that a part of that demand stems from a perception that senior dwelling communities are as prepared as some other well being care setting to cease Covid outbreaks earlier than they begin. To that finish, I do assume operators are higher outfitted now than ever earlier than to deal with resident well being wants and the potential of spreading infections. However I additionally assume the Covid vaccine – or not less than the notion that extra individuals now are vaccinated – has helped the pandemic fade into the background, and its absence can be felt.
As of the tip of 2024, about 49% of adults 75 years and older had obtained one dose of the COVID-19 vaccine for 2024 and 2025, based on the CDC. For now, vaccine makers Moderna and Pfizer are nonetheless transport their newest doses on schedule and as deliberate for the autumn and 2026.
I don’t assume the senior dwelling trade will discover itself again within the early days of 2020 given all it has discovered about an infection management. However I do surprise concerning the wider public well being implications of all of this and what that might imply for the long run. Dr. Tina Tan, who’s president of the Infectious Illness Society of America and in addition professor of pediatrics and infectious illnesses at Northwestern College, advised NPR this week she is “nervous that this places your entire American inhabitants in danger for extreme COVID illness and the issues related to it.”
With extra boundaries in place, individuals – older adults included – won’t be capable to get insurance coverage to pay for the vaccine or in different circumstances, their medical doctors and pharmacists could refuse to prescribe or administer them.
“You’re going to see a rise within the variety of people which might be hospitalized or that doubtlessly might die,” Tan advised NPR.
CDC turmoil comes with different potential worries
Whereas Covid-19 is a chief concern given experiences of potential vaccine restrictions, the turmoil on the authorities businesses additionally calls into query how properly the company can assist senior dwelling firms with different endemic well being struggles, such because the flu, RSV and norovirus. And evidently even with that preparation, these illnesses can hit laborious sufficient to affect occupancy. Simply this previous quarter, two publicly traded REITs, Ventas (NYSE: VTR) and NHI (NYSE: NHI) reported higher-than-expected resident move-out charges associated to deaths.
Public well being data flows from the CDC to the 50 U.S. states, and from there, to pharmacies and well being practitioners. Trilogy Well being Providers at the moment works with its pharmacy companions to carry vaccination clinics for not simply Covid, however RSV and different respiratory sicknesses. In line with Dr. Andrew McNamara, the operator’s chief medical officer, Trilogy has grappled with creating strong insurance policies as the assorted states the corporate is situated in have taken completely different approaches to CDC vaccine and masking suggestions.
“The extra you are able to do to encourage that tradition inside your constructing, [the better],” he mentioned throughout a panel at RETHINK. “Based mostly on location, how they interpreted a few of the vaccines and the stuff that occurred in the course of the pandemic, they’re just a little jaded. It may be laborious to say, ‘Hey, this RSV factor is absolutely essential now.’”
Even with steerage from the federal government, operators don’t all the time have a straightforward time parsing that data, particularly if they’re in a number of states. I don’t assume firings or an exodus of CDC leaders will assist that course of, on the very least. But it surely might make it tougher for senior dwelling operators or their companions to entry the data they should maintain their residents and employees protected.
It’s nonetheless unclear what the federal company may in the end do ultimately, and that uncertainty is its personal drawback. I do consider that some states will assist fill the hole if the CDC’s vaccine equipment atrophies. For instance, Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker is reportedly exploring shopping for Covid vaccines in bulk resulting from confusion concerning the street forward, with the intention of distributing them statewide.
Placing states apart, indicators level to a fair bigger vaccine and nationwide public well being shakeup forward. Kennedy has thus far in his tenure stuffed the CDC along with his personal cadre of Covid-19 response skeptics and vaccine deniers, and Monarez apparently clashed with Kennedy over “the systematic dismantling of public well being establishments, the silencing of specialists, and the harmful politicization of science,” in accordance to the New York Instances.
Whereas your entire world continues to be weary from the final 5 years, different well being points doubtlessly loom on the horizon, and never simply Covid. Though the senior dwelling trade has emerged wholesome from its first pandemic, that was with the assistance of public well being leaders, and there’s no assure that it’ll fare so properly in the course of the subsequent one ought to they lack that assist sooner or later.
